20 Worst Probiotics for Dogs: Avoid These Harmful Supplements

Probiotics for dogs have gained popularity as dietary supplements to support canine digestive health.

Many pet owners turn to these products in hopes of improving their furry companions’ gut flora and overall wellbeing.

However, not all probiotics are created equal when it comes to canine consumption.

Choosing the wrong probiotic can potentially harm a dog’s digestive system or provide little to no benefit.

Some products on the market contain ineffective strains, inadequate dosages, or even harmful ingredients for dogs.

This article examines 20 probiotic supplements that may not be suitable for canine use, helping pet owners make informed decisions about their dogs’ health.

1. Probiotic Sprinkles

Source © Shutterstock

Probiotic sprinkles for dogs have gained popularity as an easy-to-administer supplement. These products often contain dried probiotic strains in a powdered form that can be sprinkled over food.

Many probiotic sprinkles lack sufficient potency to provide meaningful benefits. The manufacturing process can damage or deactivate the beneficial bacteria, rendering them ineffective.

Some sprinkle products contain unnecessary fillers or artificial additives that may irritate a dog’s digestive system. These additives can counteract the intended benefits of the probiotics.

Storage and shelf life pose challenges for probiotic sprinkles. Exposure to heat, moisture, or air can further degrade the already fragile bacteria, reducing their efficacy even more.

2. Pet’s Best Probiotic

Pet’s Best Probiotic for dogs raises concerns among pet owners and veterinarians. This product contains questionable ingredients that may not provide optimal benefits for canine gut health.

The probiotic strains in Pet’s Best are not specifically tailored for dogs’ digestive systems. Some users report their pets experiencing gastrointestinal discomfort after consumption.

The product’s manufacturing process lacks transparency, leading to doubts about its quality and efficacy. Pet’s Best Probiotic also contains artificial additives and fillers that could potentially harm sensitive dogs.

Several pet owners have noticed no significant improvements in their dogs’ digestion or overall health after using this probiotic. The product’s packaging and storage instructions are unclear, which may compromise its effectiveness.

Given these factors, Pet’s Best Probiotic falls short of expectations for a high-quality canine supplement. Pet owners seeking to support their dogs’ digestive health may want to consider alternative options.

3. Paw Choice Probiotic

Paw Choice Probiotic has raised concerns among veterinary professionals. This product contains ingredients that may not be suitable for all dogs.

The probiotic blend in Paw Choice lacks diversity, potentially limiting its effectiveness. Some dogs have experienced digestive upset after consuming this supplement.

Quality control issues have been reported, with inconsistent results between batches. The packaging does not provide clear dosage instructions, leading to potential misuse.

Paw Choice Probiotic’s storage requirements are strict, and improper storage can reduce its potency. The product’s high price point does not necessarily reflect superior quality or results.

Some veterinarians have noted that Paw Choice Probiotic may interfere with certain medications. Dog owners should consult their vet before incorporating this supplement into their pet’s diet.

4. Purina Pro Plan FortiFlora

Purina Pro Plan FortiFlora is a widely recognized probiotic supplement for dogs. Despite its popularity, some pet owners have reported concerns about its effectiveness and ingredients.

The product contains only one strain of beneficial bacteria, Enterococcus faecium. This limited diversity may not provide the broad spectrum of benefits that multi-strain probiotics offer.

FortiFlora’s powdered form includes animal digest as a flavoring agent. Some pet owners prefer probiotics without added flavors or fillers.

The supplement’s packaging in individual sachets can be wasteful and less environmentally friendly than other options. This packaging method may also lead to higher costs per serving compared to bulk probiotic powders.

While FortiFlora is often recommended by veterinarians, its relatively high price point may deter some dog owners from consistent long-term use.

5. Ark Naturals Gentle Digest

Ark Naturals Gentle Digest is a probiotic supplement marketed for dogs with digestive issues. Despite its claims, this product falls short in several areas.

The probiotic strains used in Ark Naturals Gentle Digest are not specifically tailored for canine gut health. This lack of species-specific formulation may reduce its effectiveness in dogs.

The product contains only a single probiotic strain, limiting its potential benefits. Many veterinarians recommend multi-strain probiotics for better results in supporting canine digestive health.

The colony-forming unit (CFU) count in Ark Naturals Gentle Digest is relatively low compared to other dog probiotics on the market. This lower potency may not provide sufficient beneficial bacteria to make a noticeable difference in a dog’s gut microbiome.

Some users have reported inconsistent results when using this product for their dogs’ digestive issues. This variability in effectiveness raises concerns about its reliability as a probiotic supplement for canines.

6. Vet’s Best Probiotic

Vet’s Best Probiotic for dogs raises concerns among pet owners and veterinarians. The product contains a limited number of probiotic strains, potentially reducing its effectiveness for diverse digestive issues.

Some users report inconsistent results, with their dogs experiencing minimal improvement in digestive health. The probiotic’s potency may decrease over time, especially if not stored properly.

The product’s flavor additives could cause allergic reactions in sensitive dogs. Additionally, the packaging design makes it challenging to measure accurate doses, leading to potential under or over-supplementation.

Vet’s Best Probiotic lacks third-party testing certifications, raising questions about its quality control processes. The absence of prebiotics in the formula may limit the probiotics’ ability to thrive in the gut.

7. ProSense Probiotic Soft Chews

ProSense Probiotic Soft Chews are marketed as a digestive supplement for dogs. These chews contain a blend of probiotics and enzymes intended to support canine gut health.

Despite their appealing soft texture, these chews may not provide optimal probiotic benefits. The product’s effectiveness is questionable due to the limited variety of probiotic strains included.

Many veterinarians prefer probiotic supplements with a broader spectrum of beneficial bacteria. ProSense Chews also contain artificial flavors and preservatives, which some pet owners prefer to avoid in their dog’s diet.

The dosage instructions for these chews can be confusing, potentially leading to improper administration. This may result in reduced efficacy or unwanted side effects for some dogs.

8. Zesty Paws Advanced Probiotic

Zesty Paws Advanced Probiotic for dogs contains a blend of probiotics and enzymes. This product includes six strains of bacteria, aiming to support digestive health and immune function.

While marketed as beneficial, some dogs may experience adverse reactions to this probiotic. Potential side effects can include gastrointestinal discomfort, bloating, or diarrhea in sensitive pets.

The efficacy of Zesty Paws Advanced Probiotic varies among individual dogs. Some pet owners report no noticeable improvements in their dogs’ health after using this product.

Quality control concerns have been raised about Zesty Paws Advanced Probiotic. Inconsistent results and potential manufacturing issues may affect the product’s reliability and effectiveness for canine use.

9. Nutramax Proviable Digestive Health Supplement

Nutramax Proviable Digestive Health Supplement for dogs raises concerns among some pet owners and veterinarians. This probiotic product contains multiple strains of bacteria, which may not be suitable for all canines.

The supplement’s efficacy can vary depending on the individual dog’s digestive system and health needs. Some dogs may experience adverse reactions, such as gastrointestinal upset or allergic responses to certain ingredients.

Critics argue that the product’s bacterial strains may not colonize effectively in all dogs’ gut environments. This could potentially lead to reduced effectiveness in promoting digestive health.

The supplement’s packaging and storage requirements also pose challenges. Improper handling or exposure to heat can compromise the viability of the probiotic cultures, potentially rendering the product less effective.

Pet owners should consult with their veterinarians before administering Nutramax Proviable to ensure it aligns with their dog’s specific health requirements and to discuss potential alternatives if needed.

10. Amazing Nutritionals Probiotic Joint

Amazing Nutritionals Probiotic Joint is marketed as a supplement for dogs combining probiotics and joint support ingredients. The product contains a blend of bacterial strains along with glucosamine and chondroitin.

While probiotics can benefit canine gut health, this formula’s effectiveness for joint support is questionable. The probiotic strains and dosages used may not be optimal for dogs.

The addition of joint supplements complicates the formula. It’s unclear if the probiotic bacteria can survive alongside these other ingredients.

Quality control is another concern with this product. Some customers have reported inconsistencies in pill size and appearance between bottles.

The company makes bold claims about the supplement’s benefits that aren’t fully supported by scientific evidence. Pet owners should consult a veterinarian before using this product for their dog’s joint or digestive health needs.

11. PetVitalityPRO Probiotic

PetVitalityPRO Probiotic raises concerns among veterinary experts. The product contains a limited strain variety, potentially reducing its effectiveness for diverse canine gut issues.

Some dogs experience digestive upset when taking this probiotic. Reported side effects include diarrhea, gas, and bloating in certain cases.

The probiotic’s packaging lacks clear dosage instructions for different dog sizes. This ambiguity may lead to incorrect administration by pet owners.

Quality control issues have been noted with PetVitalityPRO. Inconsistent probiotic counts between batches can impact the product’s reliability and effectiveness.

The supplement’s shelf stability is questionable. Some users report diminished potency before the expiration date, reducing its potential benefits for dogs.

12. Pet Ultimates Probiotics

Pet Ultimates Probiotics for dogs contains a blend of six probiotic strains. The product claims to support digestive health and immune function in canines.

Despite its marketing, this probiotic supplement falls short in several areas. The strain diversity is limited compared to other options on the market, potentially reducing its effectiveness.

The colony-forming unit (CFU) count is not clearly stated on the packaging, making it difficult for pet owners to determine the potency. This lack of transparency raises concerns about the product’s quality and efficacy.

Some users have reported inconsistent results, with their dogs experiencing minimal improvements in digestive issues. Others have noted that the powder form can be challenging to administer, especially to picky eaters.

The product’s stability and shelf life are also questionable, as proper storage instructions are not prominently displayed. This may lead to reduced potency over time, diminishing any potential benefits for dogs.

13. Fur Belly Probiotic

Fur Belly Probiotic has gained attention in the pet supplement market, but it may not be the best choice for dogs. This product contains a limited range of probiotic strains, which could reduce its effectiveness for canine digestive health.

The formula includes ingredients that some dogs may find difficult to digest, potentially causing gastrointestinal discomfort. Additionally, the probiotic count per serving is lower than many veterinarian-recommended alternatives.

Some pet owners have reported inconsistent results when using Fur Belly Probiotic. While some dogs may show improvement, others experience no noticeable benefits or even adverse reactions.

The product’s packaging and storage recommendations may not adequately protect the live cultures, leading to decreased potency over time. This issue can result in dogs receiving fewer viable probiotics than intended.

14. Digestive Advantage Probiotic

Digestive Advantage Probiotic is marketed primarily for human use, not for dogs. This product contains strains of bacteria that may not be suitable for canine digestive systems.

The formulation is designed to address human-specific digestive issues and may not provide the same benefits to dogs. Using a probiotic intended for humans could potentially upset a dog’s delicate gut balance.

Veterinarians generally recommend probiotics specifically formulated for dogs. These products take into account the unique needs of canine digestive systems and contain strains proven beneficial for dogs.

Pet owners should consult with their veterinarian before giving any human-grade probiotics to their dogs. A professional can recommend appropriate probiotic supplements tailored to a dog’s individual health needs and conditions.

15. Petope Probiotic Powder

Petope Probiotic Powder raises concerns for canine health. The product lacks sufficient research to support its efficacy in dogs. Its formulation may not contain the optimal strains for canine digestive systems.

The powder’s manufacturing process is unclear, potentially compromising the viability of probiotic cultures. Some dogs may experience digestive upset when introduced to this supplement.

Petope’s packaging fails to provide detailed information about the specific probiotic strains included. This lack of transparency makes it difficult for pet owners to make informed decisions about its suitability for their dogs.

The product’s stability and shelf life are questionable, which could result in ineffective supplementation. Additionally, the dosage instructions may not be tailored to individual dog sizes and needs.

16. NaturVet Advanced Probiotic

NaturVet Advanced Probiotic is marketed as a digestive supplement for dogs. The product contains a blend of probiotics and prebiotics designed to support canine gut health.

Despite its claims, some pet owners have reported minimal improvements in their dogs’ digestive issues after using this product. The effectiveness of NaturVet Advanced Probiotic may vary depending on the individual dog’s needs and sensitivities.

One concern is the inclusion of artificial flavors in the formula. These additives may cause adverse reactions in some dogs, particularly those with sensitive stomachs or allergies.

The probiotic strains used in this product may not be as diverse or potent as those found in other canine probiotics on the market. This limited variety could potentially reduce its overall effectiveness for some dogs.

17. Nutri-Vet Probiotic Soft Chews

Nutri-Vet Probiotic Soft Chews claim to support digestive health in dogs. These chews contain a blend of probiotics and prebiotics. The product advertises its palatability and ease of administration.

Despite these claims, the probiotic strains used in Nutri-Vet Soft Chews may not be the most effective for canine gut health. The concentration of beneficial bacteria per serving is lower than in some competing products.

Some dogs may experience mild digestive upset when first introduced to these chews. This can include temporary gas or loose stools. The soft chew format, while convenient, may not preserve probiotic viability as well as other forms.

The inclusion of artificial flavors and preservatives in these chews is a concern for dogs with sensitivities. Pet owners seeking a more natural option might prefer alternatives with fewer additives.

18. Dr. Mercola Complete Probiotics

Dr. Mercola Complete Probiotics is marketed as a supplement for dogs, but it raises some concerns. The product contains a blend of 10 probiotic strains, which may seem beneficial at first glance.

However, the high number of strains can potentially cause digestive upset in some dogs. Not all probiotic strains work well together, and some may compete for resources in the gut.

Additionally, this product includes ingredients like chicory root and acacia gum. While these are meant to serve as prebiotics, they can cause gas and bloating in sensitive dogs.

The manufacturing process of Dr. Mercola probiotics has also been questioned. Some users report inconsistent quality between batches, which can affect the product’s efficacy.

Veterinarians often recommend more specialized probiotic formulations tailored specifically for canine digestive systems. These tend to have fewer strains but are more targeted to dogs’ needs.

19. Earth Animal Digestive Supplement

Earth Animal Digestive Supplement is marketed as a natural probiotic for dogs. It contains a blend of herbs and probiotics intended to support digestive health.

Despite its natural ingredients, this supplement may not be suitable for all dogs. Some canines might experience adverse reactions to the herbal components.

The product’s effectiveness can vary widely between individual dogs. Some pet owners report little to no improvement in their dog’s digestive issues after use.

The supplement’s formulation may not provide the specific probiotic strains needed for optimal canine gut health. Its broad-spectrum approach might miss targeting particular digestive concerns.

Proper dosage can be challenging to determine, potentially leading to under or over-supplementation. This uncertainty may compromise the product’s intended benefits for some dogs.

20. Mason Natural Probiotic

Mason Natural Probiotic is a supplement marketed for human consumption. It is not specifically formulated for dogs, which raises concerns about its suitability for canine use.

The product contains strains of bacteria that may not be optimal for a dog’s digestive system. These strains are selected based on human gut health needs, which differ from those of dogs.

Additionally, the dosage instructions are designed for humans, making it challenging to determine the appropriate amount for dogs of various sizes and breeds. This uncertainty could lead to under or overdosing.

The inactive ingredients in Mason Natural Probiotic may include additives or fillers that are unnecessary or potentially harmful to dogs. These components are chosen for human palatability and stability, not canine health.

Common Ingredients to Avoid

Certain probiotic ingredients can be detrimental to dogs’ health. These components may reduce product effectiveness or even cause harm.

Artificial Additives

Artificial colors and flavors have no nutritional value for dogs. They can trigger allergic reactions or digestive upset in sensitive pets. Common artificial additives include Red 40, Blue 1, and Yellow 5. These synthetic dyes may be linked to hyperactivity in some dogs.

Artificial sweeteners like xylitol are toxic to canines. Even small amounts can cause dangerous drops in blood sugar. Some probiotic manufacturers add sweeteners to improve taste, but these offer no benefits to dogs.

Fillers and Binders

Maltodextrin is a common filler in low-quality probiotics. This cheap ingredient can spike blood sugar and provides no nutritional value. It may also interfere with the effectiveness of beneficial bacteria.

Microcrystalline cellulose serves as a binding agent in many supplements. While not toxic, it can reduce the potency of probiotic strains. This filler takes up space that could be used for more beneficial ingredients.

Cornstarch is another filler to watch out for. Some dogs have corn allergies or sensitivities. It may cause digestive issues or skin problems in affected pets.

Harmful Preservatives

BHA (butylated hydroxyanisole) and BHT (butylated hydroxytoluene) are synthetic preservatives. These chemicals extend shelf life but may be carcinogenic. Long-term exposure could potentially increase cancer risk in dogs.

Sodium benzoate is a preservative that can form benzene when combined with citric acid. Benzene is a known carcinogen. This preservative may also cause hyperactivity in some pets.

Propylene glycol is used to maintain moisture in some probiotic products. It can lead to red blood cell damage in dogs. This ingredient is particularly dangerous for small breeds or those with pre-existing health conditions.

Key Factors in Choosing Probiotics

Selecting the right probiotic for dogs requires careful consideration of several crucial elements. These factors ensure the product’s quality, safety, and effectiveness for canine health.

Bacterial Strain Quality

The specific strains of bacteria in a probiotic play a vital role in its efficacy. Look for products containing well-researched strains beneficial for dogs, such as Lactobacillus acidophilus or Bifidobacterium animalis.

Strain viability is equally important. The probiotic should contain live, active cultures capable of surviving the journey through the digestive system.

Colony-forming units (CFUs) indicate the number of viable bacteria per dose. Higher CFU counts don’t always mean better results. The optimal range for dogs typically falls between 1 billion to 10 billion CFUs per serving.

Certification and Testing

Third-party testing and certifications provide assurance of a probiotic’s quality and safety. Look for products tested by independent laboratories for purity and potency.

GMP (Good Manufacturing Practice) certification indicates adherence to strict quality control standards during production.

NASC (National Animal Supplement Council) quality seal on pet supplements signifies compliance with rigorous quality standards.

Expiration dates matter. Ensure the product is within its shelf life to guarantee the potency of the probiotic strains.

Potential Allergens

Dogs with food sensitivities require extra caution when selecting probiotics. Check ingredient lists for common allergens like dairy, soy, or wheat.

Some probiotics contain additives or fillers that may trigger allergic reactions. Opt for products with minimal ingredients to reduce this risk.

Consider the probiotic’s delivery method. Powders or capsules may be preferable for dogs with specific dietary restrictions.

Prebiotic ingredients, while beneficial, can sometimes cause digestive upset in sensitive dogs. Monitor your pet’s response when introducing a new probiotic.